IMAM BUKHARI KE MURJIYA WALE QAUL KA JAYEZA..
ridwanullahi ajmain
Imam bukhari rahematulla alye imam abu hanifa rahematulla ke bare me kahete h:
"ABU HANIFA MURJAI THE..AUR MOHADDISIN NE INSE HADIS AUR RAAYE LENE ME KHAMOSHI IKHTIYAR KI HAIE."
tarikh al kabir..jild..4..safa..81.
Jawab.....
Imam bukhari ne imam abu hanifa ka zamana nahi paya..q k imam bukhari ki payedaish imam sahab ke wafat ke 44 saal baad h..
Lehaza ye murjai ki jarah imam bukhari ne apne asataza NUYAM BIN HAMMAD AL KHUZAYI se naqal kiya hai.. jinpar kaafi JURUHAAT hai.. khaas taur par ye shaks imam abu hanifa par JHOOT bolta tha..
Aur ahlul raaye se BUGHZ rakhta tha..
Nuaym bin hammad al khuzayi mohaddisin ki mizan me:
1....
IMAM NASAI rahematullahialye ne farmaya..
ZAEEF haie,, aur ek jaga farmaya: ye QAWI nahi h.
Kitab al zuaafa wal matrookeen lil nasai: 234..617.
2......
IMAM DARQUTNI rahematullaalye ne farmaya:
"kasirul wahm" yani bahot WAHM h isme
3.....
IMAM IBNE HIBBAN rahematullaalye ne apni kitab us siqat me zikr karte hue iske bare me farmaya:
KHATA bhi karta tha aur WAHAM bhi h"
4......
"IMAM ABUDAWUD rahematullaalye farmate h:
"nuaym ki 20 hadise h jinka koi ASAL nahi."
5.....
"MUSALMA BIN QASIM rahematullaalye kahete h:
"ye bahot GALTIYA (khata) karta tha aur uski hadise MUKAR h.
6.......
"Ahelul raye k khilaf nuaym bin hammad ne ayesi hadise zikr ki..jiske bare me YAHIYA BIN MA,EEN rahematullaalye ne farmaya:
"iski koi ASL nahi h."
7......
"IMAM IBNE ADEE rahematullaalye apni al kaamil fi zuaafa me shumar kiya h..aur farmaya:
"ye ahelur raye ke khilaf kitabe likhta tha."
8........
"ABBAS BIN MUS,AB rahematullaalye ne tarikh ki kitab me farmaya h k:
"Nuaym bin hammad ne hanfiyo ke radd me kaee kitabe tasnif ki h."
9.......
"IMAM ABU FATTAH AL AZDI rahematullaalye.
10..........
"AHMAD BIN SHUAIB rahematullaalye
Aur..
11.......
"ABU BISHR AL DULABI rahematullaalye
Ye tino farmate h:
"Nuaym k mutalik log kahete h ye sunnat ki difa karne me hadise GHAD(bana) diya karta tha..
Aur abu hanifa ke khilaf JHOOTI KAHAANI bayan karta jo sab ke sab JHOOT hoti thi."
12.........
"quran makhluq h...ye sawal jab Nuaym k samne awwam ne rakha to Nuaym.ne iska muttafiqa jawab naa de paya..jiske waje se inko QAID me YAQOOB FAQIA ke saat rakha gaya..
Aur san 228 hijri me iski wafat hui...
Aur ayesa likha gaya h k bina janaza ke namaz aur bina kafan ke inki tadfin hui."
13........
"IMAM IBNE JAUZI rahematullaalye ne inko apni kitab AL ZUAAFA me shumaar karke ZAEEF qarar diya h."
Kitab al zuaafa wal matrookeen lil ibn jauzi..jild..3..safa..164..raqam..3543.
Meezan ul aitadaal..jild..4..safa..267. 268. 269.. raqam..9102.
Tehzeeb at tehzeeb..jild..10..safa..462. 463. .darul kitab al ilmiya beiroot.
Al kaamil.fi zuaafa ar rijaal..jild..6..safa..2482.
14.........
"IMAM ZEHBI rahatullaalye farmate h:
"ye hadis me LAYYIN h..aur Noaym ko inhone apni kitab AL MUGNI FI ZUAAFA me bhi shumar kiya h."
IMAM ZEHBI rahematullaalye likhte h:
Nuaym bin hammad ki tasnif "kitab al fitan" me kaseer taadaad me AJIBO GARIB aur munkar hadise h."
Al mugni fi zuaafa..safa..335. 336.
Seeyar A,lam an nubla..jild..10..safa..609(muassasatur risalah)
15.........
"HAFIZ IBN HAJAR ASQALANI rahatullaalye farmate h:
"iski hadiso me WAHAM hota h."
Dusri kitab me inke bare me farmaya:
"Yuktee kaseeran" yani bahot zada GALTIYA karta tha."
Taqreeb ut Tehzeeb..safa..1006..raqam..7215.
Tehzeeb at Tehzeeb..jild..10..safa..462. 463.. Darul kitab ul ilmiya.
16........
"gayer muqallid mulana mohammed ibrahim meer siyalkoti sahab ne Nuaym bin hammad par JARAH kiya fhir farmaya:
"khulasa kalaam ye h ke Nuaym ki shakhsiyat aisi nahi h k iski riwayat ke bina par hazrat imam abu hanifa jaise buzurg imam ke haqq me BADGOI kare."
Taarikh ahele hadis..safa..85..(new edition)
KHULASA KALAM YE H K YE JARAH "NUAYM BIN HAMMAD" KI IMAM ABU HANIFA rahematullaalye KE KHILAF TAASSUB KE WAJAH SE GARDHI GAYI HAIE.
LEHAAZA USOOL E JARAH W TA,ADEEL KE TAHET "MARDOOD" HAIE.
TAALIB E DUA
Gulam Azhari
+91 9987847916
Join Whatsapp grp.
+966 5567 13059
From:-
"عشقِ نبي ﷺ"
Ishq e Nabi ﷺ Whatsapp Group
fb.com/ishq.e.nabi1
ishq-e-nabi1.blogspot.com/
ridwanullahi ajmain
Imam bukhari rahematulla alye imam abu hanifa rahematulla ke bare me kahete h:
"ABU HANIFA MURJAI THE..AUR MOHADDISIN NE INSE HADIS AUR RAAYE LENE ME KHAMOSHI IKHTIYAR KI HAIE."
tarikh al kabir..jild..4..safa..81.
Jawab.....
Imam bukhari ne imam abu hanifa ka zamana nahi paya..q k imam bukhari ki payedaish imam sahab ke wafat ke 44 saal baad h..
Lehaza ye murjai ki jarah imam bukhari ne apne asataza NUYAM BIN HAMMAD AL KHUZAYI se naqal kiya hai.. jinpar kaafi JURUHAAT hai.. khaas taur par ye shaks imam abu hanifa par JHOOT bolta tha..
Aur ahlul raaye se BUGHZ rakhta tha..
Nuaym bin hammad al khuzayi mohaddisin ki mizan me:
1....
IMAM NASAI rahematullahialye ne farmaya..
ZAEEF haie,, aur ek jaga farmaya: ye QAWI nahi h.
Kitab al zuaafa wal matrookeen lil nasai: 234..617.
2......
IMAM DARQUTNI rahematullaalye ne farmaya:
"kasirul wahm" yani bahot WAHM h isme
3.....
IMAM IBNE HIBBAN rahematullaalye ne apni kitab us siqat me zikr karte hue iske bare me farmaya:
KHATA bhi karta tha aur WAHAM bhi h"
4......
"IMAM ABUDAWUD rahematullaalye farmate h:
"nuaym ki 20 hadise h jinka koi ASAL nahi."
5.....
"MUSALMA BIN QASIM rahematullaalye kahete h:
"ye bahot GALTIYA (khata) karta tha aur uski hadise MUKAR h.
6.......
"Ahelul raye k khilaf nuaym bin hammad ne ayesi hadise zikr ki..jiske bare me YAHIYA BIN MA,EEN rahematullaalye ne farmaya:
"iski koi ASL nahi h."
7......
"IMAM IBNE ADEE rahematullaalye apni al kaamil fi zuaafa me shumar kiya h..aur farmaya:
"ye ahelur raye ke khilaf kitabe likhta tha."
8........
"ABBAS BIN MUS,AB rahematullaalye ne tarikh ki kitab me farmaya h k:
"Nuaym bin hammad ne hanfiyo ke radd me kaee kitabe tasnif ki h."
9.......
"IMAM ABU FATTAH AL AZDI rahematullaalye.
10..........
"AHMAD BIN SHUAIB rahematullaalye
Aur..
11.......
"ABU BISHR AL DULABI rahematullaalye
Ye tino farmate h:
"Nuaym k mutalik log kahete h ye sunnat ki difa karne me hadise GHAD(bana) diya karta tha..
Aur abu hanifa ke khilaf JHOOTI KAHAANI bayan karta jo sab ke sab JHOOT hoti thi."
12.........
"quran makhluq h...ye sawal jab Nuaym k samne awwam ne rakha to Nuaym.ne iska muttafiqa jawab naa de paya..jiske waje se inko QAID me YAQOOB FAQIA ke saat rakha gaya..
Aur san 228 hijri me iski wafat hui...
Aur ayesa likha gaya h k bina janaza ke namaz aur bina kafan ke inki tadfin hui."
13........
"IMAM IBNE JAUZI rahematullaalye ne inko apni kitab AL ZUAAFA me shumaar karke ZAEEF qarar diya h."
Kitab al zuaafa wal matrookeen lil ibn jauzi..jild..3..safa..164..raqam..3543.
Meezan ul aitadaal..jild..4..safa..267. 268. 269.. raqam..9102.
Tehzeeb at tehzeeb..jild..10..safa..462. 463. .darul kitab al ilmiya beiroot.
Al kaamil.fi zuaafa ar rijaal..jild..6..safa..2482.
14.........
"IMAM ZEHBI rahatullaalye farmate h:
"ye hadis me LAYYIN h..aur Noaym ko inhone apni kitab AL MUGNI FI ZUAAFA me bhi shumar kiya h."
IMAM ZEHBI rahematullaalye likhte h:
Nuaym bin hammad ki tasnif "kitab al fitan" me kaseer taadaad me AJIBO GARIB aur munkar hadise h."
Al mugni fi zuaafa..safa..335. 336.
Seeyar A,lam an nubla..jild..10..safa..609(muassasatur risalah)
15.........
"HAFIZ IBN HAJAR ASQALANI rahatullaalye farmate h:
"iski hadiso me WAHAM hota h."
Dusri kitab me inke bare me farmaya:
"Yuktee kaseeran" yani bahot zada GALTIYA karta tha."
Taqreeb ut Tehzeeb..safa..1006..raqam..7215.
Tehzeeb at Tehzeeb..jild..10..safa..462. 463.. Darul kitab ul ilmiya.
16........
"gayer muqallid mulana mohammed ibrahim meer siyalkoti sahab ne Nuaym bin hammad par JARAH kiya fhir farmaya:
"khulasa kalaam ye h ke Nuaym ki shakhsiyat aisi nahi h k iski riwayat ke bina par hazrat imam abu hanifa jaise buzurg imam ke haqq me BADGOI kare."
Taarikh ahele hadis..safa..85..(new edition)
KHULASA KALAM YE H K YE JARAH "NUAYM BIN HAMMAD" KI IMAM ABU HANIFA rahematullaalye KE KHILAF TAASSUB KE WAJAH SE GARDHI GAYI HAIE.
LEHAAZA USOOL E JARAH W TA,ADEEL KE TAHET "MARDOOD" HAIE.
TAALIB E DUA
Gulam Azhari
+91 9987847916
Join Whatsapp grp.
+966 5567 13059
From:-
"عشقِ نبي ﷺ"
Ishq e Nabi ﷺ Whatsapp Group
fb.com/ishq.e.nabi1
ishq-e-nabi1.blogspot.com/
No comments:
Post a Comment